My Rating Scale

Since my post on lists not being complete, which is an essence an amendment to my initial manifesto, I have not written many reviews, but I will have cause to with 61 Days of Halloween coming up. Keeping that in mind, it has come to my attention, both through my own ruminating and from some comments, that there is a slight incongruity to my rating scale. I have changed it very slightly at the bottom end.

I have not yet, but may still, sample my scores and average them. I know I tend to grade generously and don’t really make apologies for that. However, I’ve realized that the top end definition doesn’t mesh with the bottom end. In short, it’s easier, by definition for a 10 to be assigned than a 1. More to the point, it’s been easier to assign a 2 than a 1. Therefore, both the definition for a 10 and a 1 now include references to best in the year and downplays all-time, since that’s hard to gauge instantaneously.

Here is the altered rating scale:

Below is my rating scale. I try to be as precise as possible in describing what each number signifies. If you need further clarification please feel free to leave a comment.

1. = Terrible, no redeeming qualities, one of the worst films of the year, occasionally ever.
2. =Awful but of some minute value- among the worst of the year.
3. =A film with one maybe two strong elements but overall unforgivably poor.
4. =A film with a few mistakes too big to overlook.
5. =Marginally bad, a film with it’s good points but ultimately suffering from a fatal flaw that prevents it from achieving decency.
6. =A mediocre film; not bad but nothing special.
7. =Better than average, definitely worth viewing.
8. =A standout film with promise that is not quite fulfilled.
9. =A film which is just an iota, a minor fix or two short of greatness.
10. =A great film. Best genre can achieve, contender for best of year & rarely all-time. There are gradations in all ratings.

Advertisements

243 comments

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention My Rating Scale « The Movie Rat -- Topsy.com
  2. Pingback: Review- I Am Number Four « The Movie Rat
  3. Pingback: BAM Award Winners: Most Underrated Picture « The Movie Rat
  4. Pingback: Review- Rio « The Movie Rat
  5. Pingback: Review- Thor « The Movie Rat
  6. Pingback: Review- Fast Five « The Movie Rat
  7. Pingback: Review- Meek’s Cutoff « The Movie Rat
  8. Pingback: Review- Bridesmaids « The Movie Rat
  9. Pingback: Review- That’s What I Am « The Movie Rat
  10. Pingback: Review- The Hangover Part II « The Movie Rat
  11. Pingback: Review- The First Beautiful Thing « The Movie Rat
  12. Pingback: Review- X-Men: First Class « The Movie Rat
  13. Pingback: Review- Cave of Forgotten Dreams « The Movie Rat
  14. Pingback: Review- Super 8 « The Movie Rat
  15. Pingback: Review- Toast « The Movie Rat
  16. Pingback: Review- In a Better World « The Movie Rat
  17. Pingback: Review- The Tree of Life « The Movie Rat
  18. Pingback: Review- Green Lantern « The Movie Rat
  19. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up #1 « The Movie Rat
  20. Pingback: Review- The Art of Getting By « The Movie Rat
  21. Pingback: Review- Midnight in Paris « The Movie Rat
  22. Pingback: Review- Mr. Popper’s Penguins « The Movie Rat
  23. Pingback: Review- Judy Moody and the Not Bummer Summer « The Movie Rat
  24. Pingback: Review- Bad Teacher « The Movie Rat
  25. Pingback: Review- Secretariat « The Movie Rat
  26. Pingback: Review- You Again « The Movie Rat
  27. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up #2 « The Movie Rat
  28. Pingback: Review- Zookeeper « The Movie Rat
  29. Pingback: Review- Winnie the Pooh « The Movie Rat
  30. Pingback: Review- Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 2 « The Movie Rat
  31. Pingback: Review- NEDs « The Movie Rat
  32. Pingback: Review- Cowboys & Aliens « The Movie Rat
  33. Pingback: Review- Crazy, Stupid, Love « The Movie Rat
  34. Pingback: Review- Captain America: The First Avenger « The Movie Rat
  35. Pingback: Review- Rise of the Planet of the Apes « The Movie Rat
  36. Pingback: Review- Terri « The Movie Rat
  37. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up #3 « The Movie Rat
  38. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up #4 « The Movie Rat
  39. Pingback: Birthday Movies « The Movie Rat
  40. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Introduction and A Blade in the Dark « The Movie Rat
  41. Pingback: Review- Glee: the 3D Concert Movie « The Movie Rat
  42. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: All the Colors of the Dark « The Movie Rat
  43. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Vampire Circus « The Movie Rat
  44. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Freaks « The Movie Rat
  45. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Die, Monster, Die! « The Movie Rat
  46. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Curse « The Movie Rat
  47. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Stuff « The Movie Rat
  48. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Santa’s Slay « The Movie Rat
  49. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Homicidal « The Movie Rat
  50. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Aftermath « The Movie Rat
  51. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Genesis « The Movie Rat
  52. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Crawlspace « The Movie Rat
  53. Pingback: Review- Dolphin Tale « The Movie Rat
  54. Pingback: Review: Spy Kids: All the Time in the World in 4D « The Movie Rat
  55. Pingback: Review- Terri « The Movie Rat
  56. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Hatchet for the Honeymoon « The Movie Rat
  57. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up #5 « The Movie Rat
  58. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- It! The Terror from Beyond Space « The Movie Rat
  59. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Beast of 20,000 Fathoms « The Movie Rat
  60. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Children of the Corn (1984) « The Movie Rat
  61. Pingback: Review- Fright Night « The Movie Rat
  62. Pingback: Review- Creature « The Movie Rat
  63. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Children of the Corn III: Urban Harvest « The Movie Rat
  64. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Children of the Corn II- The Final Sacrifice « The Movie Rat
  65. Pingback: Review- Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark « The Movie Rat
  66. Pingback: Review- Our Idiot Brother « The Movie Rat
  67. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Mother’s Day « The Movie Rat
  68. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Video Dead « The Movie Rat
  69. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Prowler « The Movie Rat
  70. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Children of the Corn IV: The Gathering « The Movie Rat
  71. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Masters of Horror: Family « The Movie Rat
  72. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Evil Dead « The Movie Rat
  73. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown « The Movie Rat
  74. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Children of the Corn V: Fields of Terror « The Movie Rat
  75. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Garfield’s Halloween Adventure « The Movie Rat
  76. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Masters of Horror: Pick Me Up « The Movie Rat
  77. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Satan’s Little Helper « The Movie Rat
  78. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Masters of Horror: The V Word « The Movie Rat
  79. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween (1978) « The Movie Rat
  80. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween II (1981) « The Movie Rat
  81. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Child’s Play « The Movie Rat
  82. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Halloween III: Season of the Witch « The Movie Rat
  83. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers « The Movie Rat
  84. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers « The Movie Rat
  85. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Child’s Play 2 « The Movie Rat
  86. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers « The Movie Rat
  87. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween H20: 20 Years Later « The Movie Rat
  88. Pingback: Halloween: Resurrection « The Movie Rat
  89. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- The Amityille Horror (1979) « The Movie Rat
  90. Pingback: 61 Days o Halloween- Tremors « The Movie Rat
  91. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Friday the 13th: A New Beginning « The Movie Rat
  92. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Amityille II: The Possession « The Movie Rat
  93. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Halloween (2007) « The Movie Rat
  94. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Amityville 3D « The Movie Rat
  95. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Le Petit Nicolas « The Movie Rat
  96. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Night & Fog « The Movie Rat
  97. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- The Sea « The Movie Rat
  98. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- A Man and a Woman « The Movie Rat
  99. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Last Year at Marienbad « The Movie Rat
  100. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- The Passion of Joan of Arc « The Movie Rat
  101. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Son Frère « The Movie Rat
  102. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- The Annunciation « The Movie Rat
  103. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- The Green Room « The Movie Rat
  104. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Bicycle Thieves « The Movie Rat
  105. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- The Vanishing « The Movie Rat
  106. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- La Cage aux Folles « The Movie Rat
  107. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up January 2012 « The Movie Rat
  108. Pingback: Review- Beneath the Darkness « The Movie Rat
  109. Pingback: Review- The Devil Inside « The Movie Rat
  110. Pingback: Reviews in the Gray Area 2012 « The Movie Rat
  111. Pingback: Review- Contraband « The Movie Rat
  112. Pingback: What My Film Reviews Mean « The Movie Rat
  113. Pingback: Review- Underworld: Awakening « The Movie Rat
  114. Pingback: Review- Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close « The Movie Rat
  115. Pingback: Review- The Round Up (La Rafle) « The Movie Rat
  116. Pingback: 31 Days of Oscar Log « The Movie Rat
  117. Pingback: Short Film Saturday: The 100th Job « The Movie Rat
  118. Pingback: Review- Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade « The Movie Rat
  119. Pingback: A Reading and Review of The Turin Horse « The Movie Rat
  120. Pingback: Review- The Woman in Black « The Movie Rat
  121. Pingback: Review- Big Miracle « The Movie Rat
  122. Pingback: Journey 2: The Mysterious Island « The Movie Rat
  123. Pingback: Spielberg Sunday: Duel (1971) « The Movie Rat
  124. Pingback: Review- Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance « The Movie Rat
  125. Pingback: Spielberg Sunday- E.T.: The Extra-Terrestrial (1982) « The Movie Rat
  126. Pingback: Review- The Secret World of Arrietty « The Movie Rat
  127. Pingback: Review- Moon Child (La Permission de Minuit) « The Movie Rat
  128. Pingback: Review- John Carter « The Movie Rat
  129. Pingback: Spielberg Sunday- 1941 « The Movie Rat
  130. Pingback: Review- 21 Jump Street « The Movie Rat
  131. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up April 2012 « The Movie Rat
  132. Pingback: Review- Safe House « The Movie Rat
  133. Pingback: Review- The Hunger Games « The Movie Rat
  134. Pingback: Review- Silent House « The Movie Rat
  135. Pingback: Review- We Need to Talk About Kevin « The Movie Rat
  136. Pingback: Review- Boy « The Movie Rat
  137. Pingback: Rewind Review- Clash of the Titans (2010) « The Movie Rat
  138. Pingback: Review- Wrath of the Titans « The Movie Rat
  139. Pingback: Review- Bully « The Movie Rat
  140. Pingback: Review- The Raid: Redemption « The Movie Rat
  141. Pingback: Review- The Cabin in the Woods « The Movie Rat
  142. Pingback: Review- The Lucky One « The Movie Rat
  143. Pingback: Rewind Review- The Last Song (2010) « The Movie Rat
  144. Pingback: Rewind Review- Iron Man 2 (2010) « The Movie Rat
  145. Pingback: Review- The Avengers « The Movie Rat
  146. Pingback: Review- The Forgiveness of Blood « The Movie Rat
  147. Pingback: Rewind Review- Where the Wild Things Are (2009) « The Movie Rat
  148. Pingback: Review- Monsieur Lazhar « The Movie Rat
  149. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up May 2012 « The Movie Rat
  150. Pingback: Review- The Kid with a Bike « The Movie Rat
  151. Pingback: Rewind Review- Alice in Wonderland (2010) « The Movie Rat
  152. Pingback: Rewind Review- Little Indi « The Movie Rat
  153. Pingback: Rewind Review- The Maid « The Movie Rat
  154. Pingback: Rewind Review- Trucker (2008) « The Movie Rat
  155. Pingback: Rewind Review- Rudo y Cursi (2008) « The Movie Rat
  156. Pingback: Review- Battleship « The Movie Rat
  157. Pingback: Review- Dark Shadows « The Movie Rat
  158. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up June 2012 « The Movie Rat
  159. Pingback: Review- Chernobyl Diaries « The Movie Rat
  160. Pingback: Review- Keyhole « The Movie Rat
  161. Pingback: Comparative Analysis: The Dictator (2012) and The Great Dictator (1940) « The Movie Rat
  162. Pingback: Review- Snow White and the Huntsman « The Movie Rat
  163. Pingback: Review- Peace, Love & Misunderstanding « The Movie Rat
  164. Pingback: Review- Men in Black 3 « The Movie Rat
  165. Pingback: Review- Moonrise Kingdom « The Movie Rat
  166. Pingback: Review- In the Family « The Movie Rat
  167. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up: July 2012 « The Movie Rat
  168. Pingback: Rewind Review- Diary of a Wimpy Kid (2010) « The Movie Rat
  169. Pingback: Diary of a Wimpy Kid 2: Rodrick Rules « The Movie Rat
  170. Pingback: Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Rodrick Rules « The Movie Rat
  171. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up – August 2012 « The Movie Rat
  172. Pingback: Rewind Review- Cirque du Freak: The Vampire’s Assistant « The Movie Rat
  173. Pingback: Welcome to 61 Days of Halloween 2012 and The Call of Cthulhu « The Movie Rat
  174. Pingback: DVD Review – The Children « The Movie Rat
  175. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: The Children (2008) « The Movie Rat
  176. Pingback: Rewind Review – Case 39 « The Movie Rat
  177. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Zombieland « The Movie Rat
  178. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- A Haunting in Connecticut « The Movie Rat
  179. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Survival of the Dead « The Movie Rat
  180. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Cat in the Brain « The Movie Rat
  181. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: Vinyan « The Movie Rat
  182. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: The Sinful Dwarf « The Movie Rat
  183. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: The Final Destination « The Movie Rat
  184. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: The Final Destination « The Movie Rat
  185. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up September 2012 « The Movie Rat
  186. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up: October 2012 « The Movie Rat
  187. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween- Girl vs. Monster « The Movie Rat
  188. Pingback: Rewind Review- Black Swan « The Movie Rat
  189. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The Witman Boys « The Movie Rat
  190. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up: November 2012 « The Movie Rat
  191. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Before Tomorrow « The Movie Rat
  192. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Sin Nombre « The Movie Rat
  193. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The White Ribbon « The Movie Rat
  194. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Bergman Island « The Movie Rat
  195. Pingback: 2012 Holiday Viewing Log « The Movie Rat
  196. Pingback: Year-End Dash « The Movie Rat
  197. Pingback: Rewind Review- My One and Only « The Movie Rat
  198. Pingback: The Gray Area 2013 « The Movie Rat
  199. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up January 2013 « The Movie Rat
  200. Pingback: 31 Days of Oscar 2013 « The Movie Rat
  201. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up February 2013 « The Movie Rat
  202. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up March 2013 | The Movie Rat
  203. Pingback: DVD Review – Straight A’s | The Movie Rat
  204. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up April 2013 | The Movie Rat
  205. Pingback: DVD Review: A Royal Affair | The Movie Rat
  206. Pingback: Poverty Row April: Viewing Log and Introduction | The Movie Rat
  207. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up May 2013 | The Movie Rat
  208. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up June 2013 | The Movie Rat
  209. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up July 2013 | The Movie Rat
  210. Pingback: Tarzan Thursday: Tarzan’s New York Adventure (1942) | The Movie Rat
  211. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up August 2013 | The Movie Rat
  212. Pingback: Rewind Review: Percy Jackson & The Olympians: The Lightning Thief (2010) | The Movie Rat
  213. Pingback: Review- Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters | The Movie Rat
  214. Pingback: Birthday Movies 2013 | The Movie Rat
  215. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up Late August/September 2013 | The Movie Rat
  216. Pingback: 61 Days of Halloween: V/H/S 2 (2013) | The Movie Rat
  217. Pingback: Review: V8 – Start Your Engines! | The Movie Rat
  218. Pingback: Silent Feature Sunday- Haxan (1922) | The Movie Rat
  219. Pingback: The Book of Manning: A Personal History and Mini-Review | The Movie Rat
  220. Pingback: Mini-Review Round-Up October 2013 | The Movie Rat
  221. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Mother, I Love You (2013) | The Movie Rat
  222. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema – Paradise: Faith (2012) | The Movie Rat
  223. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Blind Spot (2012) | The Movie Rat
  224. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Short Essay and Review: In Bloom (2013) | The Movie Rat
  225. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The Green Wave (2010) | The Movie Rat
  226. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Once a Upon a Time Veronica (2012) | The Movie Rat
  227. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Mini-Review: It’s All So Quiet (2013) | The Movie Rat
  228. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: La Playa DC (2012) | The Movie Rat
  229. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Watchtower (2012) | The Movie Rat
  230. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema – The Notebook (Le Grand Cahier) (2013) | The Movie Rat
  231. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema- Class Enemy (2013) | The Movie Rat
  232. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Two Lives (2012) | The Movie Rat
  233. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The Old Man (2012) | The Movie Rat
  234. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The Fifth Season (2012) | The Movie Rat
  235. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: In the Fog (2012) | The Movie Rat
  236. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: You and the Night (2013) | The Movie Rat
  237. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The Golden Dream (La Jaula de Oro) (2013) | The Movie Rat
  238. Pingback: Dubbing Review: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (Brazilian Version) | The Movie Rat
  239. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: Child’s Pose (2013) | The Movie Rat
  240. Pingback: Thankful for World Cinema: The Color of the Chameleon (2012) | The Movie Rat
  241. Pingback: Year-End Dash: The Book Thief | The Movie Rat
  242. Pingback: Year-End Dash: The World’s End | The Movie Rat
  243. Pingback: Year-End Dash 2013 | The Movie Rat

Comments are closed.